There has been increasing amounts of conflict and violence within the United States. It saps attention and energy; of course people feel irritable and glum. This can lead to pronouncements that things will never get better, we’re doomed, etc.
Oliver Burkeman (I recommend his newsletter with enthusiasm!) quotes futurist and environmentalist Hazel Henderson and then himself comments:
“… if we can recognise that change and uncertainty are basic principles… we can greet the future… with the understanding that we do not know enough to be pessimistic.” You can take a crisis very seriously indeed without fooling yourself that you know the worst outcome is certain.
Please keep that in mind as we proceed here.
I haven’t forgotten about China’s use of psychiatrists as agents of social control. There’s stuff happening now in the United States that warrants concurrent commentary. It’s still important to know what has happened in the past. If you are itching to learn more and can’t wait for me, you can read the report from Human Rights Watch and Geneva Initiative on Psychiatry entitled Dangerous Minds: Political Psychiatry in China Today and its Origins in the Mao Era. The themes are similar to what we’re already learned together here.
The internet has been to good to me. I recently reconnected with an internet friend from the days of intueri. (Longtime readers will understand what that means.) This person has attended the protests in Minneapolis; from them I learned about Riot Medicine. Written by an anarchist medic, this manual “for practicing insurrectionary medicine” describes how medics can work in atypical settings. During protests, traditional emergency medical services may not be available. (For example, law enforcement may delay or block vehicles from entering a scene. We already know federal agents did this in Minneapolis.) It includes a short section on “Psychological Care”. It’s a summary of Psychological First Aid (introduced in my last post).
If you want to learn more about ICE Watch and Community Defense, whether in the context of protests or not, I strongly recommend this free training. What I most appreciated about the webinar was its lack of histrionics. The trainers emphasized serving as observers and avoiding escalations. Keeping a cool head is a valuable superpower during these times of dismay.
Within the deluge of actions from the federal government was this announcement: Secretary Kennedy Announces $100 Million Investment in Great American Recovery. The stated goal is to “solve long-standing homelessness issues, fight opioid addiction, and improve public safety by expanding treatment that emphasizes recovery and self-sufficiency”. This includes a new initiative:
The Safety Through Recovery, Engagement, and Evidence-based Treatment and Supports — or STREETS — Initiative will fund targeted outreach, psychiatric care, medical stabilization and crisis intervention, while connecting Americans experiencing homelessness and addiction to stable housing with a clear focus on long-term recovery and independence.
The funding attached to this is a mere $100 million. The language of this initiative is vague, so maybe $100M is enough. But if this is meant to fund a comprehensive plan for the entire nation, that sum won’t do.
Tucked further down in the announcement is this:
Secretary Kennedy also announced the $10 million Assisted Outpatient Treatment (AOT) grant program to support adults with serious mental illness. AOT is a civil court-ordered, community-based outpatient mental health treatment program for adults with serious mental illness who are unable to engage with conventional outpatient treatment and are unlikely to be able to live safely in their community.
AOT already exists in many jurisdictions, including here in Seattle-King County. While there is some evidence that AOT improves treatment adherence and reduces hospitalizations, more evaluation is needed to explain how this happens.
When I saw this news, I wondered if this was another step to use psychiatry as an agent of social control. The executive order to “end crime and disorder on America’s streets” conflates mental illnesses, substance misuse, homelessness, and crime. Now there’s funding announcements for homelessness services and court-ordered, community-based outpatient psychiatric services.
Maybe this is confirmation bias. My skepticism about the federal government’s intentions, though, is a reaction to what has already happened. May hope spring eternal and may the worst outcome never come to pass.
Maria Yang, MD 